Instruct or entertain? Constructing audiences by museum staff in Russia
Keywords:
museum, cultural institution, educational episteme, entertainment episteme, visitors, audience, participation, museum staff, exhibitionary complexAbstract
This study investigates how museum staff in Russia conceptualize their audiences in the context of evolving cultural policies and institutional requirements. The research addresses the complexity of museums as multifaceted organizations navigating the tension between preservation, education, and entertainment. Employing a qualitative methodology, the study analyzes 33 semi-structured interviews with museum professionals from 21 museums across 13 Russian regions, representing various types and ownership structures. The analysis identifies three different types of museums based on the dominant «episteme» guiding their operations and audience formation: those prioritizing educational values, those emphasizing recreational functions, and those focusing on creative engagement. Museums with a strong educational bias, often established during the Soviet era, tend to maintain traditional exhibition formats and view visitors as recipients of knowledge. Museums prioritizing entertainment, frequently emerging in the post-Soviet period, adopt interactive approaches and see visitors as customers seeking engaging experiences. Finally, creatively oriented museums, including art galleries and vernacular museums, often collaborate with local communities and view visitors as active participants in meaning-making. The findings reveal that museum staff actively shape their audiences through their understanding of the museum’s role, the design of exhibitions, and their interaction strategies. These processes are influenced by historical legacies, neoliberal cultural policies, and the increasing need for museums to engage with diverse publics. The study concludes by highlighting the varying approaches to audience construction in Russian museums and their implications for visitor engagement and museum development.Downloads
References
Абрамов и др. 2023 — Абрамов Р. Н., Баранов Д. А., Гринько И. А., Куприянов П. С., Слепцова (Кызласова) И. С., Чеснокова Е. Г. Полемические рассуждения о «вернакулярном музее» // Этнографическое обозрение. 2023. № 6. С. 111–138. https://doi.org/10.31857/S0869541523060088.
Батлер 2018 — Батлер Дж. Заметки к перформативной теории собрания / Пер. Д. Кралечкина под ред. А. Кондакова. М.: Ад Маргинем Пресс, 2018.
Кондратьева 2022 — Кондратьева С. От молчаливого присутствия к главным ролям. Креативные практики работы с наследием как стратегия соучастия // Ctrl + S. Европейское наследие / Науч. ред. С. А. Стурейко. Вильнюс: Ciklonas, 2022. С. 91–99.
Кулева 2020 — Кулева М. И. Социологические открытия «Открытых систем» // Открытые системы: Опыты художественной самоорганизации в России. 2000–2020 / Под ред. А. Ю. Трубицыной. М.: Музей современного искусства «Гараж», 2020. С. 26–33.
Максимова 2014 — Максимова А. С. Концептуальные и методологические вопросы изучения посетителей музеев // Социология: методология, методы, математическое моделирование. № 39. 2014. С. 157–188.
Максимова 2024 — Максимова А. Город и музей: пересечения и противоречия // HistoriCity: городские исследования и история современности / Под ред. Б. Степанова, К. Левинсона, О. Запорожец. М.: Нов. лит. обозрение, 2024. С. 355–385.
Музычук, Хаунина 2015 — Музычук В. Ю., Хаунина Е. А. Механизмы поддержки музеев в условиях экономического кризиса (на примере крупнейших музеев Европы и России) // Журнал Новой экономической ассоциации. 2015. № 1 (25). С. 132–161.
Нефедова 2022 — Частные музеи России: Хранители памяти и пространства / Под ред. М. Нефедовой. М.: АНО Центр «Никея», 2022.
Фуко 1999 — Фуко М. Надзирать и наказывать. Рождение тюрьмы / Пер. с фр. В. Наумова. М.: Ad Marginem, 1999.
Фуко 2004 — Фуко М. Археология знания / Пер. с фр. М. Б. Раковой, А.Ю. Серебрянниковой. СПб.: ИЦ «Гуманитарная Академия»; Университетская книга, 2004.
Фуко 2007 — Фуко М. Психиатрическая власть: Курс лекций, прочитанных в Коллеж де Франс в 1973–1974 учебном году / Пер. с фр. А. В. Шестакова. СПб.: Наука, 2007.
Щербакова 2023 — Щербакова А. Музей как агент городских изменений // Российские региональные столицы: развитие, основанное на культуре / Под ред. О. Карповой СПб.: Изд-во Европ. ун-та в С.-Петербурге, 2023. С. 232–237.
Bennett 1995 — Bennet T. The birth of the museum: History, theory, politics. London; New York: Routledge, 1995.
Bennett 2010 — Bennett T. Sociology, aesthetics, expertise // New Literary History. Vol. 41. No. 2. 2010. P. 253–276.
Boele van Hensbroek 2010 — Boele van Hensbroek P. Cultural citizenship as a normative notion for activist practices // Citizenship Studies. Vol. 14. No. 3. 2010. Р. 317–330.
Doering 1999 — Doering Z. D. Strangers, guests, or clients? Visitor experiences in museums // Curator: The Museum Journal. Vol. 42. No. 2. 1999. P. 74–87.
Gable 2013 — Gable E. The city, race, and the creation of a common history at the Virginia Historical Society // Museums and communities: Curators, collections, and collaboration / Ed. by V. Golding, W. Modest. London: Bloomsbury, 2013. P. 32–47.
Gavrilova 2023 — Gavrilova S. Russia’s regional museums: Representing and misrepresenting knowledge about nature, history, and society. London; New York: Routledge; Taylor & Francis Group, 2023.
Gigante 2024 — Gigante L. The neighborhood assembly in the art museum: Practicing cultural citizenship // Conjunctions: Transdisciplinary Journal of Cultural Participation. Vol. 11. No. 1. 2024. Р. 1–13. https://doi.org/10.2478/tjcp-2024-0003.
Hooper-Greenhill 1992 — Hooper-Greenhill E. Museums and the shaping of knowledge. New York: Routledge; Taylor & Francis Group, 1992.
Lamont et al. 2014 — Lamont M., Beljean S., Clair M. What is missing? Cultural processes and causal pathways to inequality // Socio-Economic Review. Vol. 12. Νο. 3. 2014. P. 573–608.
Lotina 2016 — Lotina L. Conceptualizing of engagement modes: Understanding museum– audience relationship in Latvian museums. Tartu: Univ. of Tartu Press, 2016.
Macdonald 2002 — Macdonald S. Behind the scenes at the science museum. Oxford; New York: Berg Publishers, 2002.
Nightingale, Mahal 2012 — Nightingale E., Mahal C. The heart of the matter: integrating equality and diversity into the policy and practice of museums and galleries // Museums, equality and social justice / Ed. by R. Sandell, E. Nightingale. New York: Routledge, 2012. P. 13–37.
Pruulmann-Vengerfeldt, Runnel 2018 — Pruulmann-Vengerfeldt P., Runnel P. The museum as an arena for cultural citizenship: Exploring modes of engagement for audience empowerment // The Routledge handbook of museums, media and communication / Ed. by K. Drotner, V. Dziekan, R. Parry, K. C. Schrøder. London: Routledge, 2018. P. 143–158.
Seph 2019 — Seph R. The personalization of the museum visit: Art museums, discourse, and visitors. New York: Routledge, 2019.
Wang, Meng 2023 — Wang Zirui, Meng Jie. Dialogues with cultural heritage via museum digitalisation: developing a model of visitors’ cognitive identity, technological agent, cultural symbolism, and public engagement // Museum Management and Curatorship. Vol. 39. No. 6. 2023. P. 810–833. https://doi.org/10.1080/09647775.2023.2269164.
