Fragments of the historians of Alexander the Great in the Naturalis Historia: Between memory and oblivion
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.22394/2412-9410-2020-6-1-26-39Keywords:
Fragmentary historians of Alexander, Book 6 of NH, Juba II, Aristobulus, Ptolemaeus, Nearchus, Arrian's AnabasisAbstract
The analysis starts from the 6th Book of the Naturalis Historia, where we can find information derived from the historians of Alexander and those others scientists who followed his expedition. Pliny thus proves to know the work of the bematists but doesn't consider at all the historiographical work of Aristobulus, and mentions Ptolemaeus only in specific dossiers regarding certain subjects. Moreover, the Naturalist declares that he drew his account from Juba II, but in terms of the passages analyzed here he consistently took inspiration from the work of Nearchus. However, Pliny made only sporadic notes about the contemporary historians of Alexander and he did not consider their importance. The passages concerning Alexander's historians in NH don't have the kind of significant role as they will have in Arrian's Anabasis: the historian from Nicomedia thinks that the achievements of Alexander the Great as Res Gestae should be used as exemplum for Trajan, while Pliny doesn't want and cannot “show as exemplum” anything to emperors Vespasian or Titus. In the contemporary political life of the Plinian age, historiography was not a very neutral refuge (in other words it wasn't something very advisable to do), especially during the last years of Nero's empire. The encyclopedic purpose of the work has strongly conditioned the content: the author of “the inventory of the World of the Flavian age” was no longer interested and fascinated by the myth of Alexander, which had been the reference point of the Imitatio Alexandri of Augustan propaganda.Downloads
References
Aly, F. (1882). Die Quellen des Plinius in achten Buch der Naturgeschichte. Marburg
N. G. Elwert. (In German).
Berger, E. H. (1903). Diognetos (16). In A. Pauly, G. Wissowa, W. Kroll, et al. (Eds.). Paulys Realencyclopädie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft (Vol. 5.1), 785. Stuttgart
J. B. Metzler Verlag (In German).
Berve, H. (1926). Das Alexanderreich Auf Prosopographischer Grundlage (Vol. 2). München: Beck. (In German).
Bosworth, A. B. (1980). A historical commentary on Arrian's History of Alexander, (Vol. 1) Commentary on Books I-III. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Bosworth, A. B. (1988). From Arrian to Alexander: Studies in historical interpretation. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Brieger, A. (1857). De fontibus librorum XXXIII, XXXIV, XXXV, XXXVI, Naturalis historiae Plinianae, quatenus ad artem plasticam pertinent (Diss). Greifswald. (In Latin).
Brown, T. S. (1949). Onesicritus: A study in Hellenistic historiography. Berkeley: Univ. of California Press.
Brunn, H. (1856). De auctorum indicibus Plinianis disputatio isagogica. Bonnae: Litteris Caroli Georgi. (In Latin).
Brunt, P. A. (1974). Notes on Aristobulus of Cassandria. The Classical Quarterly, 24(1), 65-69.
Brunt, P. A. (Ed.) (1983). Arrian, History of Alexander and Indica. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard Univ. Press.
Bucciantini, V., (2013). Misurazioni e distanze marittime nel Periplo di Nearco. In K. Geus, M. Rathmann (Eds.). Vermessung der Oikoumene: Mapping the Oikumene, 65-76. Berlin: De Gruyter. (In Italian).
Bucciantini, V., (2015). Studio su Nearco di Creta. Dalla geografia descrittiva alla narrazione storica (Studi di Storia Greca e Romana, n. 11). Alessandria: Edizioni dell'Orso. (In Italian).
Chaumont, M.-L. (1984). Études d'histoire parthe. V: La route royale des Parthes de Zeugma à Séleucie du Tigre d'après l'itinéraire d'Isidore de Charax. Syria, 61(1), 63-107. (In French).
Conte, G. B. (1982). Introduzione. In Gaio Plinio Secondo, Storia Naturale. Vol. 1. Cosmologia e geografia. Torino: Einaudi. (In Italian).
Cotta Ramosino, L. (2001). La guerra e lo sviluppo delle conoscenze geografiche in Plinio: tra condanna e valorizzazione. In M. Sordi (Ed.). Il pensiero sulla guerra nel mondo antico, 209-223. Milano: Vita e Pensiero. (In Italian).
Cresci Marrone, G. (1993). Ecumene Augustea. Una politica per il consenso. Roma: L'Erma di Bretschneider. (In Italian).
Dalstein, J. (1885). Quibus fontibus Plinius in artificum historia usus sit (Diss.). Metz. (In Latin).
De Romanis, F. (1992). Viaggi ed esplorazioni oltre i confini dell'Impero fra l'età di Plinio e quella di Tolomeo. In G. Aujac. O. Baldacci, P. Barozzi (Eds.). Optima Hereditas. Sapienza giuridica romana e conoscenza dell'ecumene, 267-274. Milano: Libri Scheiwiller. (In Italian).
Della Corte, F. (1954). App. II. La nuova lex Brunn sugli indici di Plinio. In F. Della Corte. Varrone, il terzo gran lume romano, 283-319. Genova: Pubblicazioni dell'Istituto Universitario di Magistero. (In Italian).
Detlefsen, D. (1909). Die Anordnung der geographischen Bücher des Plinius und ihre Quellen. Berlin: Weidmann. (In German).
Geier, R. (1844). Alexandri Magni historiarum scriptores aetate suppares. Leipzig: Gebauer. (In Latin).
Heckel, W. (2006). Who's who in the age of Alexander the Great. Oxford: Blackwell.
Hönigmann, E. (1926). Libye. In A. Pauly, G. Wissowa, W. Kroll, et al. (Eds.). Paulys Realencyclopädie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft, (Vol. 13), 149-202. Stuttgart: J. B. Metzler Verlag (In German).
Howe, T. (2018) Ptolemy I Soter: A self-made man. Oxford: Oxbow Books.
Jacoby, F. (Ed.) (1926-1930). Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker, (Vol. 2) B: Spezialgeschichten, Autobiographien und Memoiren, Zeittafeln [nn. 106-261]. Berlin: Weidmann. (In German).
Jacoby, F. (Ed.) (1930). Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker, (Vol. 2) D: Kommentar zu Nr. 106-261. Berlin: Weidemann. (In German).
Janni, P. (1978). "Il Sole a Destra": Estrapolazione nella Letteratura Geografica Antica e nei Resoconti di Viaggio. Studi Classici e Orientali, 28, 87-115. (In Italian).
Janni, P. (1996). Il mare degli antichi. Bari: Dedalo. (In Italian).
Janni, P. (2004). Miti e falsi miti. Luoghi comuni, leggende, errori sui Greci e sui Romani. Bari: Dedalo. (In Italian).
Khlopin, I. (1977). Die Reiseroute Isidors von Charax und die oberen Satrapien Parthiens. Iranica Antiqua, 12, 117-165. (In German).
Kirwan, L. P. (1957). Rome beyond the southern Egyptian frontier. The Geographical Journal, 123(1), 13-19.
Klotz, A. (1906). Quaestiones Plinianae geographicae (Quellen und Forschungen zur alten Geschichte und Geographie, 11). Berlin: Weidmann. (In German).
Klotz, A. (1907). Die Arbeitsweise des Älteren Plinius und die Indices Auctorum. Hermes, 42, 323-329. (In German).
Le Bonniec, H. (1946). Bibliographie de l'Histoire naturelle de Pline l'Ancien. Paris: Les Belles Lettres. (In French).
Matthews, V. J. (1974). The "Hemerodromoi": Ultra long-distance running in Antiquity. Classical World, 68(3), 161-169.
Meredith, D. (1953). Annius Plocamus: Two inscriptions from the Berenice road. Journal of Roman Studies, 43, 38-40.
Moretti, A. (2012). Introduzione ad Aristobulo. In V. Costa (Ed.). Tradizione e trasmissione degli storici greci frammentari II. Atti del III Workshop Internazionale, Roma, 24-26 febbraio 2011, 211-235. Tivoli: Edizioni Tored. (In Italian).
Moretti, A. (2013). Aristobulo e Curzio Rufo: alcuni confronti. In F. Gazzano, G. Ottone (Eds.). Le età della trasmissione. Alessandria, Roma, Bisanzio. Atti delle giornate di studio sulla storiografia greca frammentaria (Genova, 29-30 maggio 2012), 251-270. Tivoli: Edizioni Tored. (In Italian).
Münzer, F. (1897). Beiträge zur Quellenkritik der Naturgeschichte des Plinius. Berlin: Weidmann. (In German).
Pearson, L. (1952). Aristobulus the Phocian. American Journal of Philology, 73, 71-75.
Pearson, L. (1960). The lost histories of Alexander the Great (Philological Monographs; 20). New York: The American Philolological Asssociation.
Pédech, P. (1984). Historiens, Compagnons d' Alexandre. Paris: Les Belles Lettres. (In French).
Primo, A. (2009). La storiografia sui Seleucidi: da Megastene a Eusebio di Cesarea. Pisa: Fabrizio del Serra Editore. (In Italian).
Rabenhorst, M. (1907). Der Ältere Plinius als Epitomator des Verrius Flaccus. Ein Quellenanalyse des Siebenten Buches der Naturgeschichte. Berlin: Georg Reimer. (In German).
Roller, D. W. (2003). The world of Juba II and Kleopatra Selene: Royal scholarship on Rome's African frontier. London: Routledge.
Sallmann, K. G. (1971). Die Geographie des älteren Plinius in ihrem Verhältnis zu Varro. Berlin,: De Gruyter. (In German).
Schiwek, H. (1962). Der Persische Golf als Schiffahrts und Seehandelsroute in Achämenidischer Zeit und in der Zeit Alexander des Großen. Bonner Jahrbücher, 162, 4-96. (In German).
Schoff, W. H. (Ed.) (1914) Parthian Stations. By Isidore of Charax: An account of the overland trade route between the Levant and India in the first century B.C.: The Greek text, with a translation and commentary. Philadelphia: The Commercial Museum.
Schwartz, E. (1896). Baiton. In A. Pauly, G. Wissowa, W. Kroll, et al. (Eds.). Paulys Realencyclopädie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft (Vol. 2.2), 2779. Stuttgart: J. B. Metzler Verlag. (In German).
Schwartz, E. (1897). Bematistai. In A. Pauly, G. Wissowa, W. Kroll, et al. (Eds.). Paulys Realencyclopädie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft (Vol. 3), 266-267. Stuttgart: J. B. Metzler Verlag. (In German).
Sisti, F. (Ed.) (2001). Arriano. Anabasi di Alessandro I (Libri I-III). Milano: Mondadori. (In Italian).
Sprengler, J. G. (1891). Die Quellen des älteren Plinius in 12. und 13. Buch der Naturgeschichte. Rheinische Museum für Philologie, 46, 54-70. (In German).
Stadler, H. (1891). Die Quelle des Plinius im 19. Buche der Naturalis Historia. Neuburg a D.: Griessmayersche Buchdruckerei. (In German).
Stein, A. (1943). On Alexander's route into Gedrosia: An archaeological tour in Las Bela.
The Geographical Journal, 102, 193-227.
Tonnet, H. (1988). Recherches sur Arrien, sa personalité et ses écrits atticistes (2 Vols.). Amsterdam: Hakkert. (In French).
Tzifopoulos, Y. Z. (1998). ‘Hemerodromoi' and Cretan ‘dromeis': Athletes or military personnel? The case of the Cretan Philonides. Nikephoros, 11, 137-170.
Tzifopoulos, Y. Z. (2013). Bematists. In R. S. Bagnall et al. (Eds.) The encyclopedia of ancient history (Vol. 2), 1079-1080. Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781444338386.wbeah09247.
Walser, G. (1985). Die Route des Isidorus von Charax durch Iran. Archäologische Mitteilungen aus Iran. 18, 145-156. (In German).
Wirth, G. (1959). Ptolemaios als Schriftsteller und Historiker. In A. Pauly, G. Wissowa, W. Kroll, et al. (Eds.). Paulys Realencyclopädie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft (Vol. 23), 2467-2484. Stuttgart: J. B. Metzler Verlag. (In German).
Worthington, I. (2016). Ptolemy I: King and Pharaoh of Egypt. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press.
